The European Union Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS) are set of EU compliance and disclosure requirements adopted on July 31, 2023 by the European Commission, and developed by the European Financial Reporting Advisory Group (EFRAG). The ESRS are designed to make corporate sustainability and environmental social governance (ESG) reporting within the EU more accurate, common, consistent, comparable, and standardized, just like financial accounting and reporting.
The ESRS, a key provision of the EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), will apply to all companies with:
Any EU company that meets those criteria is required to file an annual report using the final ESRS guidelines, including disclosure of how sustainability influences their business, as well as the company's impact on people and the environment.
According to ESRS, companies should use the same reporting period in its sustainability reporting as the one(s) used for its financial statements. In cases where ESRS required disclosure information is already included in another financial report, that data can be referenced consistent with ESRS 1 Guidance in Chapter 5.1.
The ESRS (a reporting framework under the CSRD) is an amendment to the existing EU's Non-Financial Reporting Directive (NFRD), and will to go into effect throughout the European Union in 2023. It's estimated 50,000+ companies who do business in Europe will need to report to European regulators using the ESRS standards.
A big goal of ESRS is to reduce corporate greenwashing by standardizing and codifying material sustainability reporting for companies.
According to EFRAG:
"The overall architecture of [ESRS] Exposure Drafts is designed to ensure that sustainability information is reported in a carefully articulated manner"
However, despite the direct use of 'Sustainability' in its name, ESRS isn't just about sustainability disclosure: it shares difference reporting sections for environmental, social, and governance reporting. The ESRS aims to serve as the architecture for one annual ESG report that meets the needs of EU regulators, investors, and other stakeholders.
The second Draft ESRS standards were published by EFRAG in November 2022 and approved by the European Commission in 2023. Sector-specific sustainability reporting standards guidance will be released by June 2024.
To comply with ESRS, organization's will need to take the following annual compliance steps, beginning January 1, 2024 for the first group of eligible companies:
Similar to IFRS financial reporting standards, ESRS requires reported information to meet certain quality standards:
ESRS also notes that, in some cases, companies my need to go above and beyond ESRS's required disclosures to meet stakeholders needs or fully present the material aspects of a company's business:
"The undertaking shall disclose sustainability-related information following standardised disclosures prescribed by ESRS and when relevant through entity-specific disclosures. To achieve a high degree of comparability, disclosure requirements that are mandated for all undertakings or undertakings in a specific sector are standardised on a sector-agnostic and sector-specific bases. However, as every undertaking operates under specific facts and circumstances and deals with a unique combination of impacts, risks and opportunities, disclosure requirements mandated by ESRS may not be sufficient for the undertaking to depict in a faithful manner all its material sustainability-related impacts, risks and opportunities following its double materiality assessment. The undertaking shall therefore define, when necessary, additional entity-specific disclosures that best illustrate its unique situation."
In its current form, ESRS has twelve sections:
Brightest helps hundreds of companies measure Scope 1, 2, and 3 emissions and report on ESG compliance
As of today, the ESRS is still in draft form. However, because the CSRD was passed by EU Parliament and the EU Council in November 2022, ESRS standards will eventually become required for eligible companies under European law. The European Parliament and the European Council still have to integrate EFRAG's recommendations and public commentary, agree on a final version, and confirm the ESRS is final. These steps are expected to happen over the course of 2023. Right now, the timeline for the ESRS coming into effect is:
This means companies need to prepare to plan and implement their ESRS compliance approach by 2023 in order to be ready for the 2024 reporting cycle and stay compliant. It's not yet know exactly how the EU Commission or specific member states might penalize businesses who fail to comply with ESRS, but according to the Commissions’ requirements within the Directive, non-compliant eligible organizations will be forced to pay a meaningful fine.
EFRAG also says its "ESRS architecture foresees the preparation of sector-specific standards," but does not provide any additional guidance on them at this time.
Additionally, in a more recent June 2023 announcement, in an effort to ease the reporting burden for smaller companies, the EU Commission has proposed allowing companies with fewer than 750 employees to omit (a) Scope 3 GHG emissions data and (b) ESRS S1 “Own Workforce” disclosures in their first reporting year, and skip disclosures in the (a) ESRS E4 Biodiversity, (b) ESRS S2 "Workers in the value Chain", (c) ESRS S3 "Affected Communities", and (d) ESRS S4 "Consumers and End-users" for the their first two years' CSRD reports. All undertakings may also omit their anticipated financial effects related to non-climate environmental issues (pollution, water, biodiversity, and resource use); and certain datapoints related to their own workforce (social protection, persons with disabilities, work-related ill-health, and work-life balance) tin the first year they apply and report under CSRD's ESRS standards.
From a timing perspective, the draft ESRS standards follow closely behind the release of the International Financial Reporting Standards Foundation's initial ISSB Sustainability Reporting Standards. For those following sustainability reporting standards closely (and we certainly don't blame you if you aren't), there's some concern that ESRS and ISSB create competing standards. If Europe follows ESRS and the rest of the world to aligns with ISSB, we've got two competing standards instead of one - particularly for international companies operating in the EU and other jurisdictions.
EFRAG recognizes this problem, and, while it doesn't propose a full solution, at least shares a detailed comparison guide between ESRS and ISSB. The ISSB has also begun working directly with EFRAG to help align the two sets of sustainability reporting standards.
As you're likely already aware, the EU is implementing several new, major sustainability rules, laws, and disclosure requirements in 2023 and beyond, including the ESRS. For organizations in the early stages of their sustainability reporting journey, we have a few general recommendations, additional reading, and suggested next steps:
Materiality assessment - Materiality is a foundational aspect of the ESRS standards. Before collecting data or preparing your first ESRS report, you need to conduct a “Materiality Assessment” to determine what your sustainability opportunities, risks, impacts, and priorities are in order to properly report sustainability information under the ESRS. A materiality assessment is a project which determines and ranks the most material and impactful themes for your business based on market data, stakeholder interviews, and surveys. For example, a healthcare company might focus on healthcare access, affordability, innovation, and its supply chain. A bank should focus on ethics, financial controls, and the Scope 3 emissions in its business and lending portfolio. Pick and rank the right sustainability themes depending on your organization’s mission, sector, model, value chain, and ESG maturity. ESRS specifically uses the the lens of double materiality, meaning both sustainability impacts and financial impacts must be looked at together. According to the EU Commission: "all [ESRS] standards and all disclosure requirements and data points within each standard will be subject to materiality assessment by the undertaking, with the exception of the disclosure requirements specified in the 'General disclosures' standard"
Sustainability data systems and process - While this might go without saying, in order to report your organization's sustainability and ESG performance, you need to know what it is - with a high degree of accuracy. Your materiality process can help guide you toward the main sustainability themes you may need to focus on and collect data around. Is employee travel a big source of your organization's carbon footprint? Facilities? Manufacturing sites? Where does that data exist today, and how will you access or collect it? Many organizations start their sustainability reporting with relatively simple spreadsheets, surveys, and documents, but things can get complex fast - particularly for larger companies. If you're an organization with a medium-to-large or complex environmental footprint, you likely need dedicated sustainability reporting and data management software, like the kind we design here at Brightest to help organizations stay ESG compliant. Ongoing report archiving, version control, and governance are also important to think about, since you'll be reporting under ESRS every year.
Further reading - Our free guides to sustainability measurement, sustainability reporting, and ESG reporting provide additional, detailed guidance and insights on how to measure and report your sustainability performance. Or, if you're ready to up-level your sustainability reporting and data maturity to meet ESRS requirements, please contact us for a free assement or demo of Brightest's intelligent, award-winning ESG platform.